What can be done to reduce shootings?

Earlier in this thread I was resonding to other posts while I formulated my thoughts. Well, you beat me to the punch. I agree largely with your post, but I do want to add a couple of points. You correctly call out the socio-political changes in the US. It has been decades in the making and I would add very intentional. The radical socialist left has been working to undermine the free market and overthrow the US Constitution for over 100 years. It goes back to the original progressive movement in the early 20th Century. It has ebbed and flowed over time, but there has been a continual socialist movement every since. It started even before with the Fabian socialists in the UK, but the movement was already well developed in the US by the time Dutschke coined the phrase the, “Long march through the institutions,” which was similar to Gramsci’s concept of the “war of position”. The idea was to infiltrate the institutions of education, government, media, entertainment, etc. and undermine the US and “capitalism” from within. See Zohran Mamdami. There were other manifestations of this as well, such as Paulo Freire’s “Critical Pedagogy”. This movement was accelerated by the ascendance of postmodernism, which is antithetical to the philosophical underpinnings of the US Constitution and whose proponents were Marxist. Post modernism is now the dominant system of philosophy in the American academy.

That is how we have gotten to the place where you rightly describe the millions of Americans who have adopted the “oppresor-oppressed” culture, which is a Marxist construct. With regard to the issue of shootings, this is the part of our modern culture that contributes to political violence. The majority of leftist political violence has not been called out. Just see the riots and near daily assaults on federal buildings and ICE facilities. It is still the minority of shootings in total each year, but on the rise. The majority of violence in the US is realted to gangs, drugs, and other criminal activity, but that is a separate, yet related topic.

I think those of us who are American patriots and believe in the Constitution must recognize we are in conflict with forces that have long been at work to undermine the country with the goal of replacing our federal republic with their Marxist “utopia”. So yes, politics and political violence are downstream of culture and we must work to change the culture. There are those who do it very publically, like Charlie Kirk and are effectively building cultural movements. That is why he was assassinated. We must support those who are doing the work publically and organizing while we each play our part, talking to our children, our children’s friends, our neighbors, our fellow congregants at church (yes, it’s in the church too), etc. The vanguard, to borrow Lenin’s term, of our radical left is relatively small, but they have an outsized voice, in part amplified by certain politicians, but also because patriotic Americans have busied ourselves quietly going about our lives. I think for the moment, we still have the greater numbers, but we do need to start using our voice in honest, respectful, but direct conversations to help turn the culture back. In the mean time, yes, deter by advocating for and utilizing our 2nd Amendment right to keep and bear arms.

4 Likes

Solid copy. I agree with you 100%

…and your more detailed explanation also points to why addressing intermediate symptoms - such as “turning down the heat” on commentary and addressing “a mental health crisis” - rather than the actual root cause will not work. Unfortunately, many/most are (a) unwilling to even consider this as the root cause due to preconceived notions and (b) want “to do something” in hopes of any immediately effective solution.

2 Likes

This is a fascinating discussion and I’m learning a lot from those that have contributed. I have never understood the love affair that some have with Socialism or Marxism. It’s never worked however I do agree that there is universal equality…. in suffering. The only people who really benefit are the 0.1% who are the rulers. I’ll take poor and free over standing in lines waiting for the ruling party to take care of me.

4 Likes

The biggest threat to our democracy isn’t Liberals, Conservatives, Jews, Christians, Muslims, Atheists, whatever. It’s the extremists among them all. Extremism is the threat. It’s countered with kindness, compassion and understanding. I’m not religious, but there was this hippie, Jewish rabbi that called it a long time ago.

I am Christian and have a feeling I know that Jewish rabbi of whom you speak. If it’s who I’m thinking of, he did say love your neighbor and pray for your enemy. However, compassion can be misplaced and even with understanding, something can be opposed if morally unjust.

Extremism is a problem, but I posit there isn’t an organized extremist movement on the political right as there is on the political left…at least not yet. As evidence I give you the DSA, PSL, and their foot-soldiers/street thugs Antifa. Certainly, there are right wing extremists, but there simply isn’t any equivalent organiztion coming from the right. Furthermore, so far, the organized political right has been more effective in resisting their extremist elements. That trend is currently being tested, so we shall see, but there is no fascist equivalent of the DSA or PSL coming from the right (assuming communism and fascism are diametrically opposed along a right/left continuum). If I see such a movement growing, I’ll have to amend my position, but for now, I stand on the extreme left as the main source of threat to the Constitution and our nation.

2 Likes